The surveillance state: Security vs. privacy

Politely arguing & making your point

Free
Time 60-90 min
Type Standard
Level Upper-Intermediate

Overview

In this upper-intermediate (B2) lesson, students explore the tension between public security measures and individual privacy rights. They focus on mastering the language of polite disagreement, learning to validate opposing perspectives with diplomatic concessions before countering with their own arguments (e.g., I see your point, but..., While that may be true...).

The lesson is built around an investigative news report examining the widespread rollout of automated Flock surveillance cameras across American cities. Students analyse the arguments presented by police and civil liberties campaigners, transform blunt counter-arguments into diplomatic statements, and evaluate essential technological safeguards. They then debate municipal surveillance policies in a structured role-play before completing a short research report on an emerging surveillance technology for homework.

Outline
View Lesson Outline

Media & Worksheets

PDFs
Lesson PDFs
e-lesson
e-lesson Version
Lesson Icon

Our standard lessons follow a consistent six-stage flow: warm-up, a presentation based on real content (video, text or images), a contextual language focus stage, controlled practice, a free practice session, and a final homework task.

Each lesson includes a printable student worksheet and teacher’s guide with answer keys. For digital classrooms, we provide an editable Google Slides e-lesson, that is also compatible with PowerPoint.

The warm-up stage of our ESL conversation/speaking lesson plans

Warm-up

The purpose of this stage is to activate your students' existing knowledge and prepare them for the lesson's theme.

Activity 1: Students examine news headlines about public surveillance and discuss their initial thoughts on the topic.

The presentation stage of our ESL conversation/speaking lesson plans

Presentation

During this part of the lesson, we will introduce the main content, presenting new language and concepts through video, text or images.

Activity 2: The students will work in pairs to predict the main arguments for and against traffic surveillance cameras before watching the news report.

Activity 3: Students watch the video and note down the key arguments presented for and against the use of Flock cameras.

Activity 4: The students will have to indicate whether they agree or disagree with statements reflecting key arguments from the video.

The deeper look stage of our ESL conversation/speaking lesson plans

Language focus

This stage of of the lesson includes a contextual, interactive activity designed for presenting the target language.

Activity 5: Students examine contrasting responses to an argument about surveillance to discover the structure and tone of polite disagreement.

The controlled practice stage of our ESL conversation/speaking lesson plans

Practice

To reinforce their understanding of the new language or concepts introduced in the lesson, the students will work on a couple of controlled practice activities.

Activity 6: Students rewrite blunt disagreements about common everyday topics into diplomatic statements using prompt words in brackets.

Activity 7: The students have to write counter-arguments to different viewpoints.

Activity 8: The students will select essential safeguards for different surveillance initiatives and use polite disagreement to challenge their partner's choices.

The free practice stage of our ESL conversation/speaking lesson plans

Let's talk

We move into free practice for this stage, where the students apply the language in more open-ended, communicative activities.

Activity 9: Students discuss famous quotes about liberty, privacy, and state security with a partner.

Activity 10: The students take part in a debate over an automated municipal surveillance proposal.

The homework stage of our ESL conversation lesson plans

Homework

Finally, we'll encourage students to extend their learning outside of the classroom to reinforce the language and concepts covered during the lesson.

Homework task: Students will research an emerging public surveillance technology, summarise the arguments surrounding its use, and evaluate its impact on society.

Lesson PDFs

Lesson PDFs

Student version icon
Student Version
Teacher version icon
Teacher Version

Access the entire
TEFLHandbook library

  • ● 750+ Low-prep classroom activity ideas
  • ● 1100+ Printable ESL flashcards
  • ● 180+ ESL lesson plans
  • ● 8 Distinct language levels
  • ● Offline access through the TEFLHandbook app

Reduce your planning time and improve the way you present and teach English grammar.

Unlock icon
Become a Member
TEFLHandbook Library Preview
e-lesson
Open with Google Slides